So I noticed today that Stephen Harper has announced a $1-billion Toronto-area transit initiative. According to the
CBC's article on this initiative, it includes money for four projects:
- The extension of the Spadina-University subway into York Region;
- Bus rapid transit or dedicated bus lanes in outlying areas;
- Building an eastern extension to the 407 toll road;
- Extending Highway 404 almost to Lake Simcoe.
Clever observers will notice that the last two projects have nothing to do with public transit at all, but are extensions to existing superhighways. According to the article, Harper said that "gridlock harms the environment and causes strain on families as those in the Greater Toronto Area face some of the longest commutes in North America". How, exactly, is building more highways that feed into the city going to fix this problem?
And I can't help but think that the dedicated bus lanes aren't going to help much. Either the roads are widened to make room for the bus lanes or they aren't. If they aren't, this makes the gridlock problem worse for drivers. And even if they are, nobody will use them: in dormitory suburbs, people aren't going to want to walk all the way from their homes to the nearest arterial road to catch a bus, even if it is in a dedicated lane. They'll just stay in their cars, won't they?
My opinion is that this is a political masterstroke. Notice that, except for a few lucky residents in northwest North York and the long-suffering students of York University, nobody in Metro Toronto benefits from this new initiative. The primary beneficiaries are residents of 905-belt swing ridings, who are, right now, trying to decide whether to vote for Harper in the upcoming federal election.
But this new initiative effectively shuts Toronto up - if anybody living here complains about poor transit service again, Harper will loudly trumpet that he has just committed
one billion dollars to transit funding in the Toronto area. To the rest of the country, Toronto, Markham, Vaughan, Mississauga and so on are basically one large urban sprawl that they think of as "Toronto", so he'll get away with this. Torontonians won't be fooled, but it's not as if the Tories are going to win any seats in the city anyway.
I don't like Stephen Harper's policies, but you've got to give him credit: he's smart. He's like George W. Bush, but with brains.